Fannie’s adverse market fee, and a similar fee levied by sister GSE Freddie Mac (FRE: 8.04 0.00%) (called a market condition delivery fee), have come under fire from various industry groups since they were first introduced last year.
HW reported on the initial introduction of the fees last December, and at the time, National Association of Home Builders executive vice president and CEO Jerry Howard characterized the fees as a “broad tax on homeownership.”
Likewise, Mortgage Bankers Association chairman Kieran Quinn said he was “deeply concerned that these new fees have the potential to limit homeownership prospects for affected borrowers.” Neither organization had commented on Fannie’s decision to double such fees in the face of investor and market unrest by the time this story was published.
New loan-level pricing adjustments
Fannie also updated loan-level price adjustments for its flow purchase business, introducing LLPA credits for certain mortgage loans with credit scores of 720 and greater and loan-to-value ratios above 85 percent, and decreasing LLPAs for loans with credit scores above 620 and the same LTV levels — the changes suggest that Fannie sees these loans as less costly from a credit perspective.
“By ramping up adverse market fees by 25 basis points for all borrowers, and then crediting LLPAs 25 basis points for some subset of borrowers, the effect of Fannie’s change is a net wash,” said one source, an analyst that asked not to be identified by name. “At least, for that subset only.”
Sources suggested, however, it was strange to see low-equity loans get a 25 basis point pricing credit, while loans between the 60 and 85 percent LTV received no such favorable treatment from the GSE — in fact, depending on credit strata, some loans in this lower LTV range actually saw LLPAs increased.
“It may be a reflection of the current market dynamic,” said the analyst that spoke with us, “but it’s certainly odd to see pricing adjustments favor higher LTV loans.”
Another source said the pricing changes were made because the GSE is pushing the decision-making power and authority for low-equity loans directly into insurers’ collective laps.
“High LTVs are getting ‘lower’ fees because Fannie is ready to double down on PMIs,” said the source, via email.
Freddie Mac had not yet followed suit, but market sources suggested the GSE would soon hike its own fees in response to the move by Fannie Mae.
Related links: Fannie Mae Lender Announcement 08-18